Gazing at the California initiative proposed in Proposition 71, the Wisconsin Journal Times speculates that Wisconsin may fall behind. Now, this would be a reasonable fear in most US states. But Wisconsin? As Alta Charo acknowledges, “UW-Madison has strong adult and embryonic stem cell programs for now because all the federally allowed embryonic cell lines are at the university…” Finally, someone comes close to admitting that Wisconsin benefits enormously from the policy presided over by its former governor, HHS head Tommy Thompson. It is arguably a huge advantage, giving enormous intellectual property protection to the corporation started by Wisconsin’s alumni association to hold (and collect fees for licensing) patents on the discoveries of James Thompson and colleagues at Wisconsin, and to collect fees for the use of Wisconsin’s “Bush-approved” cell lines. Those patents, by the way, cover a huge range of activities in embryo engineering and science – virtually ensuring Wisconsin a place at the table in any embryonic stem cell-based IP dispute. So it is a surprise that Charo notes that Wisconsin “should be, by far, the single state everybody in the world looks to for the first, best discoveries on both embryonic and adult stem cells. And we’re not.”
Labels: Alta Charo, brain drain, hESC, state stem cell politics, Wisconsin