Two years ago, I wrote a blog for Bioethics Today where I decried the triumph of entertainment values over civic virtues. Entertainment values focus on superficial spectacle. Civic virtues require a commitment to a set of common values. I argued that the election of Trump signaled that civic virtues had no chance against the pervasively pernicious values of entertainment which are meant to distract from, minimize or even neglect serious issues in favor of trivial amusements. I finished my piece by stating the following: “The reality is that half of our country believes the next four years will be a dystopia while the other half believes it will be a utopia.” This month’s blue tsunami suggested that Americans had had enough of what Atlantic editor-in-chief David Remnick called the “performance art” of the administration. The Trump show had finally “jumped the shark.”
One of the more incisive pieces written about the Trump administration was penned by Stephen Marche. In this March 3, 2025, Atlantic piece, Marche captured the essence of the current administration—rather than being simply an oligarchy, it’s a “histriocracy”:
It is rule by performers….Rule by performers is distinct from autocracy. The ruling performers serve the narrative needs of their fans first and foremost. Policy will always be an addendum to the show….Under rule by performers, only one law is inviolable: The show must go on, until the curtain falls.
Does the recent election suggest that Americans are once again committed to the civic virtues of honesty, justice, and the rule of law? In my justice and healthcare course, I teach my students that there is an ongoing push and pull in US politics. A progressive political movement will seemingly usher in a new era, resulting in some meaningful healthcare reform (such as the ACA). Yet, predictably, there is almost always an intense reactionary backlash against such movements. The rise of Trumpism reflected this backlash. And the “genius” of Trump was to create a histriocracy where spectacle is revered above all else—meaningful policy is relegated to the back burner.
The “misinfotainment industrial complex” that has propagated so much misinformation and disinformation met an electorate that was exhausted by the constant onslaught of falsehoods and propaganda. Physicians such as Amy Acton, Annie Andrews, and Abdul El-Sayed won against much better funded opponents. Less well-known physicians, such as Richard Pan, Amish Shah, and Adam Hamaway, all won seats in the House. In an era marked by anti-intellectualism and anti-public health, public health won a notable victory. This new generation of health care professionals will have the opportunity to rebuild the damage done to trust toward public health with the current leadership of HHS.
This new leadership is facing significant challenges when it comes to healthcare. The One Big Beautiful Bill was an example of a reactionary politics that punishes people on Medicaid by imposing new work requirements and conditions on eligibility. These new requirements impose unjust administrative burdens on people who may have limited digital literacy or the time to fill out forms. These new cuts will also affect the SNAP program, which affects millions of children.
The recent midterms strongly suggest that millions of Americans are tired of the histriocracy and kakistocracy of this administration. New leadership has committed itself to helping to reduce the cost of healthcare and expand coverage. A key goal is to restore the Affordable Care Act’s subsidies. As Sandro Galea has argued, we need a public health based on love, not hate. The past decade has been a none-too-real reality show that has elevated hate and “othering.” A recommitment to civic virtues such as honesty, justice, and even love signal that our nation is finally turning a new leaf after years of an anti-virtue leadership committed to vice.
Kayhan Parsi, JD, PhD, is Professor and Graduate Program Director at the Neiswanger Institute for Bioethics, Loyola University Chicago Stritch School of Medicine and is the John B. Francis Co-Chair in Bioethics at the Center for Practical Bioethics.