Why High School Bioethics Education Is Important and How a High School Club Is Advancing It

Author

Dhara Ashar and Lisa Kearns, MS, MA

Publish date

Why High School Bioethics Education Is Important and How a High School Club Is Advancing It
Topic(s): Professional Ethics

High school students encounter bioethical questions everywhere: in science and health classes, with their increasing use of AI, when consuming genetically modified food, in family conversations about medical care. Engaging in bioethical discussions offers many benefits for these younger students, from better reasoning skills to critical thinking and decision-making. Political attacks on evidence-based science and medicine make these discussions among the next generation of science and health professionals more necessary than ever.

However, students rarely have structured environments in which to participate in ethics discussions. A high school bioethics club, conceived by a junior and developed with resources from the NYU Grossman School of Medicine High School Bioethics Project, provides such an environment and can serve as a model for other students and schools. Below we describe how the Chatham High School Ethics Club was launched at a school in New Jersey, how it works in practice, and, importantly, why it matters for high schoolers. 

Research on bioethics instruction in high school classrooms has shown that student engagement with bioethics material changes how they think, leaving a positive long-term impact on their development. When students are exposed to core bioethics concepts, their ability to analyze ethically troubling cases improves. Engaging in ethical debates sharpens critical thinking, the ability to engage across different viewpoints, and debate skills overall. Bioethics instruction also allows students to interact with science in an unfamiliar way that encourages deeper engagement with—and excitement about—STEM and healthcare. UNESCO has recognized these benefits in the context of research integrity in its Universal Declaration on the Human Genome and Human Rights, Article 20, where it explicitly encourages states to foster bioethics education “at all levels.”

The need for high school bioethics education extends beyond academic benefits. The current political attacks on evidence-based science and medicine and decades-long public health policies make earlier bioethics engagement with the next generation of research and health professionals increasingly urgent, almost a form of pre-professional training. Despite the midterm election results, there’s not much reason to think the Trump administration won’t continue to sideline well-established and long-trusted scientific guidance, censor or defund research, and prioritize political ideology over scientific evidence. Drastic federal funding cuts targeting scientific research, vaccines, climate monitoring and public health grants, and threaten health innovation and patient outcomes. High schoolers will be the ones to have to counter these attacks as part of their eventual practices of medicine and research.

Younger generations are also entering a world defined by medical breakthroughs such as human gene editing, raising questions about safety, oversight, equity, and potential heritable changes, and the rise of AI-generated health information and diagnostics, which can spread inaccurate information at scale and raise questions about transparency and accountability. These are bioethical challenges, which the next generation ought to learn to regard through an ethics lens. 

Despite these benefits of bioethics education, it can be difficult to integrate it into school curricula. Teachers have limited additional instructional time and must adhere to standardized curricula. School clubs, then, are a promising solution to these constraints. Clubs function as a “third space” outside structured classes, where students can freely explore complex topics away from the instruction of teachers and the formality of classrooms. Additionally, in a club, students can study current cases relevant to modern developments, allowing them to explore important ethical questions informed by relevant information.

The Chatham High School (CHS) Ethics Club in New Jersey is a case study in creating a forum for students to learn various bioethics topics. The creator (Ashar) launched the club in 2025 after seeing significant peer interest in ethical debates, with the goal of creating a forum for peer discussion and insights from experts in the field. She structured meetings around lesson plans from the NYU Grossman School of Medicine High School Bioethics Project in the Section of Medical Ethics. Through online resources, internships, and mentorship, the project works to provide an ethics foundation for future generations of STEM and healthcare professionals. The Ethics Club discussed topics from genetic modification and environmental ethics to vaccine ethics and the ethics of childhood sports participation. Each lesson plan has background readings, discussion questions, activities, and case studies. 

The format of the club is simple: Members vote on which HSBP lesson plan to discuss and spend five to six meetings working through it. Early meetings introduce essential background and definitions, often through an activity or game rather than a lecture, to maximize engagement. Later meetings shift to discussing the ethical controversies and possible solutions. Every topic culminates in a discussion with an NYU Section of Medical Ethics–affiliated content expert, who presents a new case study and guides students through live discussion. This provides them access to expert perspectives without requiring guidance, or time, from any classroom teachers. 

The club saw significant student interest and success during 2025, covering three topics. It has gained more than 87 members since its launch and is set to discuss four topics in 2026-’27. (CHS’s student population is ~1,200.) 

High schoolers are capable of complex ethical thinking and have demonstrated interest in and awareness of the necessity to learn about the field. However, a chief obstacle to advancing this interest is the lack of opportunity to facilitate these discussions. A club like the CHS Ethics Club can give students a space for the kind of open-ended discussion that could be difficult in a structured, traditional classroom setting. The CHS club is one example of what that can look like in practice, but the model is intended to be adaptable and expandable. For students or teachers wondering whether this could work at their school, the tools already exist. What’s needed now is the willingness to start. 

Dhara Ashar is a senior at Chatham High School and an intern at Bioethics International.

Lisa Kearns, MS, MA, is a research scientist and the director of the High School Bioethics Project in the Section of Medical Ethics, NYU Grossman School of Medicine.